Preparing for an initial public offering (IPO) is often a strenuous undertaking. Companies strive to ensure that all their affairs are in order before they submit their S-1 filing to the SEC. This is done primarily to make sure that the initial public offering IPO is well received by investors.

WeWork

WeWork first filed its prospectus on August 14th 2019. Two main components of the filing prompted investor backlash. First and foremost, investors were alarmed at WeWork’s consecutive and increasing financial losses over the past three years. Secondly, investors took note of the company’s unusual governance practices. Although a justification could be provided for the financial losses, namely that they were essential to their growth strategy, no justification could be provided for the latter. With lazy governance practices increasingly linked to poor company performance, WeWork responded by making sweeping changes to assuage concerns.

Women on Boards

Gender diversity on boards has become a prominent issue in recent years. Some major investors, such as Blackrock, have even updated their voting guidelines to try and work towards a more equal representation. In light of this, investors were surprised and disappointed when WeWork’s initial filing included seven board members, all of which were male. In response, WeWork quickly recruited renowned culture coach Frances Frei to their board.

Frei earned her reputation when she was hired by Uber to help fix their “Bro Culture”. Although this a step in the right direction, WeWork might benefit from adding more women to their portfolio of directors. Using CGLytics data and intelligence a trendline can be made, in the S&P 500 real estate industry, between the percentage of women on boards and a company’s Average 1-year Total Shareholder Return (TSR).

Women on boards versus average TSR

Source: CGLytics Data and Analytics

CGLytics’ data and analytics are trusted and used worldwide by Glass Lewis, the leading independent proxy advisor, as a basis for their research on companies

 

Voting Rights

Also included in WeWorks initial filing were plans to award the company’s founders and early investors 20 votes for each share of Class Stock. This would grant unchecked power to the CEO. Moreover, in the event that the Chief Executive Officer, Adam Neumann, would become incapacitated, then his wife, Rebekah Neumann, and two directors would decide who the successor would be.

This plan has subsequently been scrapped and been replaced by a more contemporary policy where the Board of Directors holds the power to pick a successor. In regard to the voting rights, the number of votes for each share of Class A stock will now only account for 10 votes each.

WeWork has had a tumultuous build-up to their IPO. Many investors were hesitant to back the company as their corporate governance policies did not meet their standards. WeWork is just one example of many where Corporate Governance plays an integral role in the health and viability of a company, especially when third parties are involved.

For more information regarding how CGLytics’ deep, global data set and unparalleled analytical screening tools can potentially help you make better decisions, click here.

About the Author

Jaco Fourie: U.S. Research Analyst

Jaco holds a Bachelor of Science degree in Accounting and Finance from the University of Reading. He has gained experience as a research analyst from his enrollment at the Henley Business School and the International Capital Market Association Centre.

Latest Industry News, Views & Information

Blue Sky Downfall – What went wrong?

While no company wants to find itself in a state of voluntary administration, it is a stark reality faced by the Australian-based fund manager Blue Sky Alternative Investments Limited. The company is currently undergoing administration, following years of challenging circumstances starting as early as 2017.

Harvey Norman AGM; Strike 2 in the making?

Harvey Norman’s Annual General Meeting is to be held this Wednesday November 27, 2019. With leading independent proxy advisor CGI Glass Lewis advising to vote against the reappointment of the company’s chief executive, Katie Page, and the remuneration report, the gloves are off.

Boeing: What has been done? And will that be enough?

Will changes to Boeing’s board be enough to sharpen focus on product and safety going forward? This article examines Boeing’s corporate governance practices and current board expertise, bringing to light some interesting findings.